Dialogue courtesy of IMDB, and yes, spoilers...
Dr. Lisa Cuddy: She's not a crack baby.
Dr. Gregory House: No, mother's perfectly healthy. She just had to give up the baby in order to continue her work on the human genome.
Dr. Lisa Cuddy: She confessed to some past meth use.
Dr. Gregory House: What they don't confess to is almost always more interesting. This is a mistake.
i am a big watcher of "House". we recently obtained cable, but continue to watch episodes online, as we're always one episode behind. i've been needling Chris for days that we need to catch up on the most recent episode, and he's been reluctant, knowing it was about adoption. so last night i watched it by myself, when he went out to do "guy stuff".
since head administrator Cuddy has wanted a baby for a few seasons now, as shown by her attempt with IVF, i wasn't surprised by her turning to adoption. and generally, i like Cuddy's character. however.
let me begin by saying that of course the expectant mom is young, not really educated, has a history of family yuck and of course, past drug use. and of course this past use may (or may not, its never clearly stated) have contributed to the baby's lungs being underdeveloped, which we find out mid-episode.
while there is an agency mentioned early on, there is no sight or sound of them...ever. Cuddy meets Becca (the expectant mom) at a restaurant, just the two of them. Becca has a kooky rash on her arm and Cuddy whisks her away to the hospital where she becomes Becca's primary caregiver. never a mention of "who do we call for you?". in short, there is nobody on Becca's side. nobody. and a very entangled & involved Cuddy whose baby-fever is so outrageous, i cringed every time she opened her mouth. the character clearly has no boundaries in this episode.
so when it comes the point of "deliver the baby & baby might not live" or "wait to deliver baby & possibly jeopardize Becca", Cuddy is all about waiting to deliver and makes it crystal clear to Becca. but Becca is rightfully scared with this news and opts to deliver via C-section. of course, Cuddy is present in the operating room.
long story short: baby lives, Cuddy is blooming in new mommmyhood for all of 4.5 minutes and Becca decides to parent, thoughtfully musing that this baby will change her life for the better. of course Cuddy is devastated, throwing all sorts of "are you sure you want to do this?" language.
at the tail end of the show, when Cuddy is shown teary & aimless at home, there's a knock on the door. i honestly thought it would be Becca, realizing she had made a "mistake". however it's simply House, and he & Cuddy get to some "grief making out". many of the message boards i read last night about this episode were so focused on this development. but come on, who among us hasn't done something weird/inappropriate in a time of high emotional stress?
i know: it's a TV show and fiction and 44 minutes long. i'll probably never be satisfied with how expectant parents facing adoption or birth/first parents are portrayed in the media. and i'll inwardly cringe when a show i like takes a storyline down this path.
but really, this episode was nothing compared to the shock & horror of seeing a TV ad for the agency i placed though, while trying to relax with some guilty pleasure Clean House on the Style Channel. to paraphrase the reaction of a friend... it made me throw up in my mouth a little.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)





10 comments:
Have you seen Brother's and Sisters? It's on ABC and this season has brought adoption into the episodes. The Nov 9th episode the couple met their expectant mother.
It's the first show I've seen with mostly positive adoption language.
People keep telling me to watch House and blog it but I don't want to. reading this makes me want to even less. Argh.
Oh -- I google shared it!!
Infertility is never shown fairly or accurately either. The TV peeps either don't care or are too stupid to accurately reflect such emotionally difficult obstacles in life.
I saw that show and didn't even know how to approach blogging it. All I know it, I watched it, feeling a whole lot of the "ick" factor when I watched it. That was a hard one, and actually the one before was difficult too (the one with the adult adoptee from China, if you saw it).
I wonder if Cuddy will try again. *sigh*
I watch House - it's the closest thing I have to a religion. On the other hand, I haven't and won't blog about it.
Having said that, there was some weird, bordering-on-inappropriate stuff on a while back about Cuddy's struggles w/IF and/or "baby quest". I haven't seen this episode yet - and now I'll be avoiding it - but it doesn't surprise me.
I've never seen that show. Sounds like an awful episode. 30Rock pissed me off a couple of weeks ago with an adoption storyline, though.
debbie_b - i haven't seen Brothers & Sisters, but i've heard murmurings of it. i'll have to check it out at some point.
dawn - yeah, it was hard to fit all my feelings into one post...but its one of the two shows i watch regularly... i felt obligated to write something.
me - except for Cuddy, i haven't seen too many shows with infertility, but i'm usually in bed by 630! and its hitting a little too close to home for me at the moment.
Judy - yeaaaaah...the one before with the young woman who was adopted was tough too...that made my head hurt. i saw on twit that you had watched House. there was a lot of ground to cover.
spyderkl - i know what you mean about the religious watching of House. for me its House and Ugly Betty. uh, yeah, the "inappropraite" level is set to "stun".
clem - i have 30 Rock in my netflix queue, down about 30 listings...haven't seen an episode yet. but i'll probably watch it when it comes around.
Thanks for your blog. As a House fan I was not thrilled with that episode and hate the false portrayals of infertility and adoption. Someone gave me Chicken Soup for the Adopted Soul and I read almost the whole thing after House to get myself some great inspiration and adoption joy! I recommend that book...
You could write a book, it doesn't have to be about adoption issues even. You really are a good writer, natural, clear and powerful.
Post a Comment